Distinct Chopper Timing settings (#19781)

Co-authored-by: Scott Lahteine <github@thinkyhead.com>

Marlin/Configuration_adv.h

@@ -2471,10 +2471,26 @@
    * CHOPPER_PRUSAMK3_24V // Imported parameters from the official Průša firmware for MK3 (24V)
    * CHOPPER_MARLIN_119   // Old defaults from Marlin v1.1.9
    *
-   * Define you own with
+   * Define your own with:
    * { <off_time[1..15]>, <hysteresis_end[-3..12]>, hysteresis_start[1..8] }
    */
-  #define CHOPPER_TIMING CHOPPER_DEFAULT_12V
+  #define CHOPPER_TIMING CHOPPER_DEFAULT_12V        // All axes (override below)
+  //#define CHOPPER_TIMING_X  CHOPPER_DEFAULT_12V   // For X Axes (override below)
+  //#define CHOPPER_TIMING_X2 CHOPPER_DEFAULT_12V
+  //#define CHOPPER_TIMING_Y  CHOPPER_DEFAULT_12V   // For Y Axes (override below)
+  //#define CHOPPER_TIMING_Y2 CHOPPER_DEFAULT_12V
+  //#define CHOPPER_TIMING_Z  CHOPPER_DEFAULT_12V   // For Z Axes (override below)
+  //#define CHOPPER_TIMING_Z2 CHOPPER_DEFAULT_12V
+  //#define CHOPPER_TIMING_Z3 CHOPPER_DEFAULT_12V
+  //#define CHOPPER_TIMING_Z4 CHOPPER_DEFAULT_12V
+  //#define CHOPPER_TIMING_E  CHOPPER_DEFAULT_12V   // For Extruders (override below)
+  //#define CHOPPER_TIMING_E1 CHOPPER_DEFAULT_12V
+  //#define CHOPPER_TIMING_E2 CHOPPER_DEFAULT_12V
+  //#define CHOPPER_TIMING_E3 CHOPPER_DEFAULT_12V
+  //#define CHOPPER_TIMING_E4 CHOPPER_DEFAULT_12V
+  //#define CHOPPER_TIMING_E5 CHOPPER_DEFAULT_12V
+  //#define CHOPPER_TIMING_E6 CHOPPER_DEFAULT_12V
+  //#define CHOPPER_TIMING_E7 CHOPPER_DEFAULT_12V
 
   /**
    * Monitor Trinamic drivers

Marlin/src/module/stepper/trinamic.cpp

@@ -36,7 +36,7 @@
 #include <SPI.h>
 
 enum StealthIndex : uint8_t { STEALTH_AXIS_XY, STEALTH_AXIS_Z, STEALTH_AXIS_E };
-#define TMC_INIT(ST, STEALTH_INDEX) tmc_init(stepper##ST, ST##_CURRENT, ST##_MICROSTEPS, ST##_HYBRID_THRESHOLD, stealthchop_by_axis[STEALTH_INDEX])
+#define TMC_INIT(ST, STEALTH_INDEX) tmc_init(stepper##ST, ST##_CURRENT, ST##_MICROSTEPS, ST##_HYBRID_THRESHOLD, stealthchop_by_axis[STEALTH_INDEX], chopper_timing_##ST)
 
 //   IC = TMC model number
 //   ST = Stepper object letter
@@ -131,15 +131,15 @@ enum StealthIndex : uint8_t { STEALTH_AXIS_XY, STEALTH_AXIS_Z, STEALTH_AXIS_E };
 
 #if HAS_DRIVER(TMC2130)
   template<char AXIS_LETTER, char DRIVER_ID, AxisEnum AXIS_ID>
-  void tmc_init(TMCMarlin<TMC2130Stepper, AXIS_LETTER, DRIVER_ID, AXIS_ID> &st, const uint16_t mA, const uint16_t microsteps, const uint32_t hyb_thrs, const bool stealth) {
+  void tmc_init(TMCMarlin<TMC2130Stepper, AXIS_LETTER, DRIVER_ID, AXIS_ID> &st, const uint16_t mA, const uint16_t microsteps, const uint32_t hyb_thrs, const bool stealth, const chopper_timing_t &chop_init) {
     st.begin();
 
     CHOPCONF_t chopconf{0};
-    chopconf.tbl = 1;
-    chopconf.toff = chopper_timing.toff;
+    chopconf.tbl = 0b01;
+    chopconf.toff = chop_init.toff;
     chopconf.intpol = INTERPOLATE;
-    chopconf.hend = chopper_timing.hend + 3;
-    chopconf.hstrt = chopper_timing.hstrt - 1;
+    chopconf.hend = chop_init.hend + 3;
+    chopconf.hstrt = chop_init.hstrt - 1;
     TERN_(SQUARE_WAVE_STEPPING, chopconf.dedge = true);
     st.CHOPCONF(chopconf.sr);
 
@@ -166,15 +166,15 @@ enum StealthIndex : uint8_t { STEALTH_AXIS_XY, STEALTH_AXIS_Z, STEALTH_AXIS_E };
 
 #if HAS_DRIVER(TMC2160)
   template<char AXIS_LETTER, char DRIVER_ID, AxisEnum AXIS_ID>
-  void tmc_init(TMCMarlin<TMC2160Stepper, AXIS_LETTER, DRIVER_ID, AXIS_ID> &st, const uint16_t mA, const uint16_t microsteps, const uint32_t hyb_thrs, const bool stealth) {
+  void tmc_init(TMCMarlin<TMC2160Stepper, AXIS_LETTER, DRIVER_ID, AXIS_ID> &st, const uint16_t mA, const uint16_t microsteps, const uint32_t hyb_thrs, const bool stealth, const chopper_timing_t &chop_init) {
     st.begin();
 
     CHOPCONF_t chopconf{0};
-    chopconf.tbl = 1;
-    chopconf.toff = chopper_timing.toff;
+    chopconf.tbl = 0b01;
+    chopconf.toff = chop_init.toff;
     chopconf.intpol = INTERPOLATE;
-    chopconf.hend = chopper_timing.hend + 3;
-    chopconf.hstrt = chopper_timing.hstrt - 1;
+    chopconf.hend = chop_init.hend + 3;
+    chopconf.hstrt = chop_init.hstrt - 1;
     TERN_(SQUARE_WAVE_STEPPING, chopconf.dedge = true);
     st.CHOPCONF(chopconf.sr);
 
@@ -484,7 +484,7 @@ enum StealthIndex : uint8_t { STEALTH_AXIS_XY, STEALTH_AXIS_Z, STEALTH_AXIS_E };
 
 #if HAS_DRIVER(TMC2208)
   template<char AXIS_LETTER, char DRIVER_ID, AxisEnum AXIS_ID>
-  void tmc_init(TMCMarlin<TMC2208Stepper, AXIS_LETTER, DRIVER_ID, AXIS_ID> &st, const uint16_t mA, const uint16_t microsteps, const uint32_t hyb_thrs, const bool stealth) {
+  void tmc_init(TMCMarlin<TMC2208Stepper, AXIS_LETTER, DRIVER_ID, AXIS_ID> &st, const uint16_t mA, const uint16_t microsteps, const uint32_t hyb_thrs, const bool stealth, const chopper_timing_t &chop_init) {
     TMC2208_n::GCONF_t gconf{0};
     gconf.pdn_disable = true; // Use UART
     gconf.mstep_reg_select = true; // Select microsteps with UART
@@ -495,10 +495,10 @@ enum StealthIndex : uint8_t { STEALTH_AXIS_XY, STEALTH_AXIS_Z, STEALTH_AXIS_E };
 
     TMC2208_n::CHOPCONF_t chopconf{0};
     chopconf.tbl = 0b01; // blank_time = 24
-    chopconf.toff = chopper_timing.toff;
+    chopconf.toff = chop_init.toff;
     chopconf.intpol = INTERPOLATE;
-    chopconf.hend = chopper_timing.hend + 3;
-    chopconf.hstrt = chopper_timing.hstrt - 1;
+    chopconf.hend = chop_init.hend + 3;
+    chopconf.hstrt = chop_init.hstrt - 1;
     TERN_(SQUARE_WAVE_STEPPING, chopconf.dedge = true);
     st.CHOPCONF(chopconf.sr);
 
@@ -526,7 +526,7 @@ enum StealthIndex : uint8_t { STEALTH_AXIS_XY, STEALTH_AXIS_Z, STEALTH_AXIS_E };
 
 #if HAS_DRIVER(TMC2209)
   template<char AXIS_LETTER, char DRIVER_ID, AxisEnum AXIS_ID>
-  void tmc_init(TMCMarlin<TMC2209Stepper, AXIS_LETTER, DRIVER_ID, AXIS_ID> &st, const uint16_t mA, const uint16_t microsteps, const uint32_t hyb_thrs, const bool stealth) {
+  void tmc_init(TMCMarlin<TMC2209Stepper, AXIS_LETTER, DRIVER_ID, AXIS_ID> &st, const uint16_t mA, const uint16_t microsteps, const uint32_t hyb_thrs, const bool stealth, const chopper_timing_t &chop_init) {
     TMC2208_n::GCONF_t gconf{0};
     gconf.pdn_disable = true; // Use UART
     gconf.mstep_reg_select = true; // Select microsteps with UART
@@ -537,10 +537,10 @@ enum StealthIndex : uint8_t { STEALTH_AXIS_XY, STEALTH_AXIS_Z, STEALTH_AXIS_E };
 
     TMC2208_n::CHOPCONF_t chopconf{0};
     chopconf.tbl = 0b01; // blank_time = 24
-    chopconf.toff = chopper_timing.toff;
+    chopconf.toff = chop_init.toff;
     chopconf.intpol = INTERPOLATE;
-    chopconf.hend = chopper_timing.hend + 3;
-    chopconf.hstrt = chopper_timing.hstrt - 1;
+    chopconf.hend = chop_init.hend + 3;
+    chopconf.hstrt = chop_init.hstrt - 1;
     TERN_(SQUARE_WAVE_STEPPING, chopconf.dedge = true);
     st.CHOPCONF(chopconf.sr);
 
@@ -568,14 +568,14 @@ enum StealthIndex : uint8_t { STEALTH_AXIS_XY, STEALTH_AXIS_Z, STEALTH_AXIS_E };
 
 #if HAS_DRIVER(TMC2660)
   template<char AXIS_LETTER, char DRIVER_ID, AxisEnum AXIS_ID>
-  void tmc_init(TMCMarlin<TMC2660Stepper, AXIS_LETTER, DRIVER_ID, AXIS_ID> &st, const uint16_t mA, const uint16_t microsteps, const uint32_t, const bool) {
+  void tmc_init(TMCMarlin<TMC2660Stepper, AXIS_LETTER, DRIVER_ID, AXIS_ID> &st, const uint16_t mA, const uint16_t microsteps, const uint32_t, const bool, const chopper_timing_t &chop_init) {
     st.begin();
 
     TMC2660_n::CHOPCONF_t chopconf{0};
-    chopconf.tbl = 1;
-    chopconf.toff = chopper_timing.toff;
-    chopconf.hend = chopper_timing.hend + 3;
-    chopconf.hstrt = chopper_timing.hstrt - 1;
+    chopconf.tbl = 0b01;
+    chopconf.toff = chop_init.toff;
+    chopconf.hend = chop_init.hend + 3;
+    chopconf.hstrt = chop_init.hstrt - 1;
     st.CHOPCONF(chopconf.sr);
 
     st.sdoff(0);
@@ -590,15 +590,15 @@ enum StealthIndex : uint8_t { STEALTH_AXIS_XY, STEALTH_AXIS_Z, STEALTH_AXIS_E };
 
 #if HAS_DRIVER(TMC5130)
   template<char AXIS_LETTER, char DRIVER_ID, AxisEnum AXIS_ID>
-  void tmc_init(TMCMarlin<TMC5130Stepper, AXIS_LETTER, DRIVER_ID, AXIS_ID> &st, const uint16_t mA, const uint16_t microsteps, const uint32_t hyb_thrs, const bool stealth) {
+  void tmc_init(TMCMarlin<TMC5130Stepper, AXIS_LETTER, DRIVER_ID, AXIS_ID> &st, const uint16_t mA, const uint16_t microsteps, const uint32_t hyb_thrs, const bool stealth, const chopper_timing_t &chop_init) {
     st.begin();
 
     CHOPCONF_t chopconf{0};
-    chopconf.tbl = 1;
-    chopconf.toff = chopper_timing.toff;
+    chopconf.tbl = 0b01;
+    chopconf.toff = chop_init.toff;
     chopconf.intpol = INTERPOLATE;
-    chopconf.hend = chopper_timing.hend + 3;
-    chopconf.hstrt = chopper_timing.hstrt - 1;
+    chopconf.hend = chop_init.hend + 3;
+    chopconf.hstrt = chop_init.hstrt - 1;
     TERN_(SQUARE_WAVE_STEPPING, chopconf.dedge = true);
     st.CHOPCONF(chopconf.sr);
 
@@ -625,15 +625,15 @@ enum StealthIndex : uint8_t { STEALTH_AXIS_XY, STEALTH_AXIS_Z, STEALTH_AXIS_E };
 
 #if HAS_DRIVER(TMC5160)
   template<char AXIS_LETTER, char DRIVER_ID, AxisEnum AXIS_ID>
-  void tmc_init(TMCMarlin<TMC5160Stepper, AXIS_LETTER, DRIVER_ID, AXIS_ID> &st, const uint16_t mA, const uint16_t microsteps, const uint32_t hyb_thrs, const bool stealth) {
+  void tmc_init(TMCMarlin<TMC5160Stepper, AXIS_LETTER, DRIVER_ID, AXIS_ID> &st, const uint16_t mA, const uint16_t microsteps, const uint32_t hyb_thrs, const bool stealth, const chopper_timing_t &chop_init) {
     st.begin();
 
     CHOPCONF_t chopconf{0};
-    chopconf.tbl = 1;
-    chopconf.toff = chopper_timing.toff;
+    chopconf.tbl = 0b01;
+    chopconf.toff = chop_init.toff;
     chopconf.intpol = INTERPOLATE;
-    chopconf.hend = chopper_timing.hend + 3;
-    chopconf.hstrt = chopper_timing.hstrt - 1;
+    chopconf.hend = chop_init.hend + 3;
+    chopconf.hstrt = chop_init.hstrt - 1;
     TERN_(SQUARE_WAVE_STEPPING, chopconf.dedge = true);
     st.CHOPCONF(chopconf.sr);
 

Marlin/src/module/stepper/trinamic.h

@@ -76,7 +76,18 @@ typedef struct {
   uint8_t hstrt;
 } chopper_timing_t;
 
-static constexpr chopper_timing_t chopper_timing = CHOPPER_TIMING;
+#ifndef CHOPPER_TIMING_X
+  #define CHOPPER_TIMING_X CHOPPER_TIMING
+#endif
+#ifndef CHOPPER_TIMING_Y
+  #define CHOPPER_TIMING_Y CHOPPER_TIMING
+#endif
+#ifndef CHOPPER_TIMING_Z
+  #define CHOPPER_TIMING_Z CHOPPER_TIMING
+#endif
+#ifndef CHOPPER_TIMING_E
+  #define CHOPPER_TIMING_E CHOPPER_TIMING
+#endif
 
 #if HAS_TMC220x
   void tmc_serial_begin();
@@ -90,9 +101,10 @@ void reset_trinamic_drivers();
 // X Stepper
 #if AXIS_IS_TMC(X)
   extern TMC_CLASS(X, X) stepperX;
+  static constexpr chopper_timing_t chopper_timing_X = CHOPPER_TIMING_X;
   #if ENABLED(SOFTWARE_DRIVER_ENABLE)
     #define X_ENABLE_INIT() NOOP
-    #define X_ENABLE_WRITE(STATE) stepperX.toff((STATE)==X_ENABLE_ON ? chopper_timing.toff : 0)
+    #define X_ENABLE_WRITE(STATE) stepperX.toff((STATE)==X_ENABLE_ON ? chopper_timing_X.toff : 0)
     #define X_ENABLE_READ() stepperX.isEnabled()
   #endif
   #if AXIS_HAS_SQUARE_WAVE(X)
@@ -103,9 +115,10 @@ void reset_trinamic_drivers();
 // Y Stepper
 #if AXIS_IS_TMC(Y)
   extern TMC_CLASS(Y, Y) stepperY;
+  static constexpr chopper_timing_t chopper_timing_Y = CHOPPER_TIMING_Y;
   #if ENABLED(SOFTWARE_DRIVER_ENABLE)
     #define Y_ENABLE_INIT() NOOP
-    #define Y_ENABLE_WRITE(STATE) stepperY.toff((STATE)==Y_ENABLE_ON ? chopper_timing.toff : 0)
+    #define Y_ENABLE_WRITE(STATE) stepperY.toff((STATE)==Y_ENABLE_ON ? chopper_timing_Y.toff : 0)
     #define Y_ENABLE_READ() stepperY.isEnabled()
   #endif
   #if AXIS_HAS_SQUARE_WAVE(Y)
@@ -116,9 +129,10 @@ void reset_trinamic_drivers();
 // Z Stepper
 #if AXIS_IS_TMC(Z)
   extern TMC_CLASS(Z, Z) stepperZ;
+  static constexpr chopper_timing_t chopper_timing_Z = CHOPPER_TIMING_Z;
   #if ENABLED(SOFTWARE_DRIVER_ENABLE)
     #define Z_ENABLE_INIT() NOOP
-    #define Z_ENABLE_WRITE(STATE) stepperZ.toff((STATE)==Z_ENABLE_ON ? chopper_timing.toff : 0)
+    #define Z_ENABLE_WRITE(STATE) stepperZ.toff((STATE)==Z_ENABLE_ON ? chopper_timing_Z.toff : 0)
     #define Z_ENABLE_READ() stepperZ.isEnabled()
   #endif
   #if AXIS_HAS_SQUARE_WAVE(Z)
@@ -129,9 +143,13 @@ void reset_trinamic_drivers();
 // X2 Stepper
 #if HAS_X2_ENABLE && AXIS_IS_TMC(X2)
   extern TMC_CLASS(X2, X) stepperX2;
+  #ifndef CHOPPER_TIMING_X2
+    #define CHOPPER_TIMING_X2 CHOPPER_TIMING_E
+  #endif
+  static constexpr chopper_timing_t chopper_timing_X2 = CHOPPER_TIMING_X2;
   #if ENABLED(SOFTWARE_DRIVER_ENABLE)
     #define X2_ENABLE_INIT() NOOP
-    #define X2_ENABLE_WRITE(STATE) stepperX2.toff((STATE)==X_ENABLE_ON ? chopper_timing.toff : 0)
+    #define X2_ENABLE_WRITE(STATE) stepperX2.toff((STATE)==X_ENABLE_ON ? chopper_timing_X2.toff : 0)
     #define X2_ENABLE_READ() stepperX2.isEnabled()
   #endif
   #if AXIS_HAS_SQUARE_WAVE(X2)
@@ -142,9 +160,13 @@ void reset_trinamic_drivers();
 // Y2 Stepper
 #if HAS_Y2_ENABLE && AXIS_IS_TMC(Y2)
   extern TMC_CLASS(Y2, Y) stepperY2;
+  #ifndef CHOPPER_TIMING_Y2
+    #define CHOPPER_TIMING_Y2 CHOPPER_TIMING_E
+  #endif
+  static constexpr chopper_timing_t chopper_timing_Y2 = CHOPPER_TIMING_Y2;
   #if ENABLED(SOFTWARE_DRIVER_ENABLE)
     #define Y2_ENABLE_INIT() NOOP
-    #define Y2_ENABLE_WRITE(STATE) stepperY2.toff((STATE)==Y_ENABLE_ON ? chopper_timing.toff : 0)
+    #define Y2_ENABLE_WRITE(STATE) stepperY2.toff((STATE)==Y_ENABLE_ON ? chopper_timing_Y2.toff : 0)
     #define Y2_ENABLE_READ() stepperY2.isEnabled()
   #endif
   #if AXIS_HAS_SQUARE_WAVE(Y2)
@@ -155,9 +177,13 @@ void reset_trinamic_drivers();
 // Z2 Stepper
 #if HAS_Z2_ENABLE && AXIS_IS_TMC(Z2)
   extern TMC_CLASS(Z2, Z) stepperZ2;
+  #ifndef CHOPPER_TIMING_Z2
+    #define CHOPPER_TIMING_Z2 CHOPPER_TIMING_E
+  #endif
+  static constexpr chopper_timing_t chopper_timing_Z2 = CHOPPER_TIMING_Z2;
   #if ENABLED(SOFTWARE_DRIVER_ENABLE) && AXIS_IS_TMC(Z2)
     #define Z2_ENABLE_INIT() NOOP
-    #define Z2_ENABLE_WRITE(STATE) stepperZ2.toff((STATE)==Z_ENABLE_ON ? chopper_timing.toff : 0)
+    #define Z2_ENABLE_WRITE(STATE) stepperZ2.toff((STATE)==Z_ENABLE_ON ? chopper_timing_Z2.toff : 0)
     #define Z2_ENABLE_READ() stepperZ2.isEnabled()
   #endif
   #if AXIS_HAS_SQUARE_WAVE(Z2)
@@ -168,9 +194,13 @@ void reset_trinamic_drivers();
 // Z3 Stepper
 #if HAS_Z3_ENABLE && AXIS_IS_TMC(Z3)
   extern TMC_CLASS(Z3, Z) stepperZ3;
+  #ifndef CHOPPER_TIMING_Z3
+    #define CHOPPER_TIMING_Z3 CHOPPER_TIMING_E
+  #endif
+  static constexpr chopper_timing_t chopper_timing_Z3 = CHOPPER_TIMING_Z3;
   #if ENABLED(SOFTWARE_DRIVER_ENABLE)
     #define Z3_ENABLE_INIT() NOOP
-    #define Z3_ENABLE_WRITE(STATE) stepperZ3.toff((STATE)==Z_ENABLE_ON ? chopper_timing.toff : 0)
+    #define Z3_ENABLE_WRITE(STATE) stepperZ3.toff((STATE)==Z_ENABLE_ON ? chopper_timing_Z3.toff : 0)
     #define Z3_ENABLE_READ() stepperZ3.isEnabled()
   #endif
   #if AXIS_HAS_SQUARE_WAVE(Z3)
@@ -181,9 +211,13 @@ void reset_trinamic_drivers();
 // Z4 Stepper
 #if HAS_Z4_ENABLE && AXIS_IS_TMC(Z4)
   extern TMC_CLASS(Z4, Z) stepperZ4;
+  #ifndef CHOPPER_TIMING_Z4
+    #define CHOPPER_TIMING_Z4 CHOPPER_TIMING_E
+  #endif
+  static constexpr chopper_timing_t chopper_timing_Z4 = CHOPPER_TIMING_Z4;
   #if ENABLED(SOFTWARE_DRIVER_ENABLE)
     #define Z4_ENABLE_INIT() NOOP
-    #define Z4_ENABLE_WRITE(STATE) stepperZ4.toff((STATE)==Z_ENABLE_ON ? chopper_timing.toff : 0)
+    #define Z4_ENABLE_WRITE(STATE) stepperZ4.toff((STATE)==Z_ENABLE_ON ? chopper_timing_Z4.toff : 0)
     #define Z4_ENABLE_READ() stepperZ4.isEnabled()
   #endif
   #if AXIS_HAS_SQUARE_WAVE(Z4)
@@ -194,9 +228,13 @@ void reset_trinamic_drivers();
 // E0 Stepper
 #if AXIS_IS_TMC(E0)
   extern TMC_CLASS_E(0) stepperE0;
+  #ifndef CHOPPER_TIMING_E0
+    #define CHOPPER_TIMING_E0 CHOPPER_TIMING_E
+  #endif
+  static constexpr chopper_timing_t chopper_timing_E0 = CHOPPER_TIMING_E0;
   #if ENABLED(SOFTWARE_DRIVER_ENABLE) && AXIS_IS_TMC(E0)
     #define E0_ENABLE_INIT() NOOP
-    #define E0_ENABLE_WRITE(STATE) stepperE0.toff((STATE)==E_ENABLE_ON ? chopper_timing.toff : 0)
+    #define E0_ENABLE_WRITE(STATE) stepperE0.toff((STATE)==E_ENABLE_ON ? chopper_timing_E0.toff : 0)
     #define E0_ENABLE_READ() stepperE0.isEnabled()
   #endif
   #if AXIS_HAS_SQUARE_WAVE(E0)
@@ -207,9 +245,13 @@ void reset_trinamic_drivers();
 // E1 Stepper
 #if AXIS_IS_TMC(E1)
   extern TMC_CLASS_E(1) stepperE1;
+  #ifndef CHOPPER_TIMING_E1
+    #define CHOPPER_TIMING_E1 CHOPPER_TIMING_E
+  #endif
+  static constexpr chopper_timing_t chopper_timing_E1 = CHOPPER_TIMING_E1;
   #if ENABLED(SOFTWARE_DRIVER_ENABLE) && AXIS_IS_TMC(E1)
     #define E1_ENABLE_INIT() NOOP
-    #define E1_ENABLE_WRITE(STATE) stepperE1.toff((STATE)==E_ENABLE_ON ? chopper_timing.toff : 0)
+    #define E1_ENABLE_WRITE(STATE) stepperE1.toff((STATE)==E_ENABLE_ON ? chopper_timing_E1.toff : 0)
     #define E1_ENABLE_READ() stepperE1.isEnabled()
   #endif
   #if AXIS_HAS_SQUARE_WAVE(E1)
@@ -220,9 +262,13 @@ void reset_trinamic_drivers();
 // E2 Stepper
 #if AXIS_IS_TMC(E2)
   extern TMC_CLASS_E(2) stepperE2;
+  #ifndef CHOPPER_TIMING_E2
+    #define CHOPPER_TIMING_E2 CHOPPER_TIMING_E
+  #endif
+  static constexpr chopper_timing_t chopper_timing_E2 = CHOPPER_TIMING_E2;
   #if ENABLED(SOFTWARE_DRIVER_ENABLE) && AXIS_IS_TMC(E2)
     #define E2_ENABLE_INIT() NOOP
-    #define E2_ENABLE_WRITE(STATE) stepperE2.toff((STATE)==E_ENABLE_ON ? chopper_timing.toff : 0)
+    #define E2_ENABLE_WRITE(STATE) stepperE2.toff((STATE)==E_ENABLE_ON ? chopper_timing_E2.toff : 0)
     #define E2_ENABLE_READ() stepperE2.isEnabled()
   #endif
   #if AXIS_HAS_SQUARE_WAVE(E2)
@@ -233,9 +279,13 @@ void reset_trinamic_drivers();
 // E3 Stepper
 #if AXIS_IS_TMC(E3)
   extern TMC_CLASS_E(3) stepperE3;
+  #ifndef CHOPPER_TIMING_E3
+    #define CHOPPER_TIMING_E3 CHOPPER_TIMING_E
+  #endif
+  static constexpr chopper_timing_t chopper_timing_E3 = CHOPPER_TIMING_E3;
   #if ENABLED(SOFTWARE_DRIVER_ENABLE) && AXIS_IS_TMC(E3)
     #define E3_ENABLE_INIT() NOOP
-    #define E3_ENABLE_WRITE(STATE) stepperE3.toff((STATE)==E_ENABLE_ON ? chopper_timing.toff : 0)
+    #define E3_ENABLE_WRITE(STATE) stepperE3.toff((STATE)==E_ENABLE_ON ? chopper_timing_E3.toff : 0)
     #define E3_ENABLE_READ() stepperE3.isEnabled()
   #endif
   #if AXIS_HAS_SQUARE_WAVE(E3)
@@ -246,9 +296,13 @@ void reset_trinamic_drivers();
 // E4 Stepper
 #if AXIS_IS_TMC(E4)
   extern TMC_CLASS_E(4) stepperE4;
+  #ifndef CHOPPER_TIMING_E4
+    #define CHOPPER_TIMING_E4 CHOPPER_TIMING_E
+  #endif
+  static constexpr chopper_timing_t chopper_timing_E4 = CHOPPER_TIMING_E4;
   #if ENABLED(SOFTWARE_DRIVER_ENABLE) && AXIS_IS_TMC(E4)
     #define E4_ENABLE_INIT() NOOP
-    #define E4_ENABLE_WRITE(STATE) stepperE4.toff((STATE)==E_ENABLE_ON ? chopper_timing.toff : 0)
+    #define E4_ENABLE_WRITE(STATE) stepperE4.toff((STATE)==E_ENABLE_ON ? chopper_timing_E4.toff : 0)
     #define E4_ENABLE_READ() stepperE4.isEnabled()
   #endif
   #if AXIS_HAS_SQUARE_WAVE(E4)
@@ -259,9 +313,13 @@ void reset_trinamic_drivers();
 // E5 Stepper
 #if AXIS_IS_TMC(E5)
   extern TMC_CLASS_E(5) stepperE5;
+  #ifndef CHOPPER_TIMING_E5
+    #define CHOPPER_TIMING_E5 CHOPPER_TIMING_E
+  #endif
+  static constexpr chopper_timing_t chopper_timing_E5 = CHOPPER_TIMING_E5;
   #if ENABLED(SOFTWARE_DRIVER_ENABLE) && AXIS_IS_TMC(E5)
     #define E5_ENABLE_INIT() NOOP
-    #define E5_ENABLE_WRITE(STATE) stepperE5.toff((STATE)==E_ENABLE_ON ? chopper_timing.toff : 0)
+    #define E5_ENABLE_WRITE(STATE) stepperE5.toff((STATE)==E_ENABLE_ON ? chopper_timing_E5.toff : 0)
     #define E5_ENABLE_READ() stepperE5.isEnabled()
   #endif
   #if AXIS_HAS_SQUARE_WAVE(E5)
@@ -272,9 +330,13 @@ void reset_trinamic_drivers();
 // E6 Stepper
 #if AXIS_IS_TMC(E6)
   extern TMC_CLASS_E(6) stepperE6;
+  #ifndef CHOPPER_TIMING_E6
+    #define CHOPPER_TIMING_E6 CHOPPER_TIMING_E
+  #endif
+  static constexpr chopper_timing_t chopper_timing_E6 = CHOPPER_TIMING_E6;
   #if ENABLED(SOFTWARE_DRIVER_ENABLE) && AXIS_IS_TMC(E6)
     #define E6_ENABLE_INIT() NOOP
-    #define E6_ENABLE_WRITE(STATE) stepperE6.toff((STATE)==E_ENABLE_ON ? chopper_timing.toff : 0)
+    #define E6_ENABLE_WRITE(STATE) stepperE6.toff((STATE)==E_ENABLE_ON ? chopper_timing_E6.toff : 0)
     #define E6_ENABLE_READ() stepperE6.isEnabled()
   #endif
   #if AXIS_HAS_SQUARE_WAVE(E6)
@@ -285,9 +347,13 @@ void reset_trinamic_drivers();
 // E7 Stepper
 #if AXIS_IS_TMC(E7)
   extern TMC_CLASS_E(7) stepperE7;
+  #ifndef CHOPPER_TIMING_E7
+    #define CHOPPER_TIMING_E7 CHOPPER_TIMING_E
+  #endif
+  static constexpr chopper_timing_t chopper_timing_E7 = CHOPPER_TIMING_E7;
   #if ENABLED(SOFTWARE_DRIVER_ENABLE) && AXIS_IS_TMC(E7)
     #define E7_ENABLE_INIT() NOOP
-    #define E7_ENABLE_WRITE(STATE) stepperE7.toff((STATE)==E_ENABLE_ON ? chopper_timing.toff : 0)
+    #define E7_ENABLE_WRITE(STATE) stepperE7.toff((STATE)==E_ENABLE_ON ? chopper_timing_E7.toff : 0)
     #define E7_ENABLE_READ() stepperE7.isEnabled()
   #endif
   #if AXIS_HAS_SQUARE_WAVE(E7)